The Feast of the Seven Fishes is a beloved Italian-American Christmas Eve tradition. Families gather around tables overflowing with seafood, laughter, and good wine.
These eight main fish recipes will help you create an unforgettable holiday feast that honors this cherished custom while satisfying every palate at your table.
From hearty stews that warm the soul to elegant baked fish preparations, these Italian seafood recipes for the Feast of the Seven Fishes bring something special for everyone.
Each dish offers its own unique flavors and cooking style, adding excitement to your Christmas Eve celebration.
Maybe you’re hosting your first Feast of the Seven Fishes, or you’re just looking to shake things up with a couple of new recipes. These picks range from cozy fisherman’s stews to restaurant-worthy baked fish, making holiday cooking feel totally doable, and honestly, a little more fun.
Table of Content
Seven Fishes Stew
A seven fishes stew recipe gives you a simple way to keep this Italian Christmas Eve tradition alive. One big pot, tons of seafood, and a broth that just gets better as it simmers.
The stew usually brings together a mix of firm fish and shellfish. Cod, salmon, shrimp, mussels, clams, scallops, and calamari all work beautifully.
- Saves time on Christmas Eve
- Uses local seafood options
- Feeds a crowd easily
Many cooks whip up the tomato base ahead of time. That way, the flavors deepen and you sidestep last-minute chaos.
Honestly, this dish is perfect if you want the tradition but don’t want to fuss with seven separate courses. It’s all the seafood, all together, in one soul-warming bowl.
Don’t stress about finding every single kind of fish, just use what’s fresh or frozen and local. This recipe is forgiving, and that’s part of its charm.
Garlicky Swordfish
Swordfish has this meaty, satisfying texture that stands up to bold flavors, especially garlic. It makes a fantastic centerpiece for Christmas Eve.
Garlicky swordfish Calabrian style leans into the best of southern Italian coastal cooking.
- Quick cooking time
- Bold Mediterranean flavors
- Perfect for entertaining
This recipe loves simple, quality ingredients. Garlic leads the way, with fresh herbs and olive oil bringing everything together.
Cooking Method: Pan-searing gives the fish a golden crust, while the garlic works its way right into every bite.
Even if you’re new to cooking fish, this one’s hard to mess up. The technique is straightforward, and the results taste like something from a great little trattoria.
Swordfish pairs nicely with roasted veggies or a tangle of pasta. Throw it on the table with other seafood and you’ve got variety covered.
Citrus Swordfish
Swordfish again, but this time with a citrusy twist. It’s a little unexpected, but it totally works, especially if you’re looking to break out of the usual feast lineup.
The fish’s firm texture stands up to grilling or pan-searing. Bright hits of lemon, orange, or lime keep things lively.
- Unique option – stands out from typical feast fish
- Easy preparation – cooks quickly and evenly
- Bold flavors – citrus cuts through the richness
- Impressive presentation – restaurant-quality results
Citrus swordfish with chimichurri brings a fresh, herbal pop of color to the plate. That green sauce is a showstopper.
Shoot for medium-rare with swordfish steaks, overcook them and they’ll turn tough. Nobody wants that.
- Pat steaks dry before cooking
- Season 15 minutes before cooking
- Use high heat for good sear
- Rest for 3-5 minutes after cooking
The citrus marinade does double duty, keeping the fish juicy and adding bright flavor. Orange, lemon, and herbs find a nice balance without overpowering.
This main dish sits happily next to roasted veggies or pasta. The bold flavors play well with other seafood, too, nothing gets lost.
Baked Salmon Fillet
Baked salmon is a crowd-pleaser and makes a gorgeous centerpiece for Christmas Eve. It cooks evenly in the oven and feeds a bunch of people without much fuss.
Families love this one for its simplicity. A quick and easy baked salmon lets you focus on the rest of the meal, or just hang out with family.
- Requires minimal active cooking time
- Feeds large groups well
- Stays moist when baked properly
The salmon fillet bakes at a steady temperature, and you can dress it up with herbs, lemon, or a little garlic.
Timing matters. Most fillets need about 12-15 minutes per inch of thickness. You’ll know it’s ready when the fish flakes easily with a fork.
Salmon’s mild taste appeals to just about everyone, making it a safe bet for a mixed crowd.
Cioppino Stew
Cioppino is the ultimate Christmas Eve seafood tradition for many Italian-American families. This Italian-American seafood stew started in San Francisco, built on whatever the fishermen brought home that day.
The stew blends shrimp, crab, mussels, clams, and different fish in a tomato and wine broth. It’s a real showcase dish for Christmas Eve.
- Dungeness crab
- Fresh shrimp
- Mussels
- Clams
- White fish fillets
- Scallops
- Calamari
Start with onions, garlic, and fennel in olive oil, then build the broth with tomatoes, white wine, and herbs. The flavors come together in a way that just feels festive.
Cioppino is great for holiday dinner parties because it easily feeds a crowd. Bonus: it tastes even better the next day.
Serve this rustic fisherman’s stew with crusty sourdough bread. You’ll want every drop of that broth.
Seven Fishes Pie
Seven Fishes Pie is comfort food meets tradition. It layers fish and seafood under a golden, flaky pastry that’s as pretty as it is delicious.
The feast of the seven fishes pie makes a dramatic centerpiece for the holiday table. Go for seven different seafood varieties or keep it simple with just a couple.
- Scallops and shrimp
- White fish like cod or halibut
- Salmon or sea bass
- Crab or lobster
Some recipes get fancy with lobster tail and caviar. Others stick with affordable classics like canned tuna or anchovy paste.
The filling usually has a creamy base, think crème fraiche or béchamel. Fresh herbs like parsley, dill, or basil brighten everything up.
Make the filling ahead and assemble the pie on Christmas Eve. The golden crust makes it festive and practical for feeding a big group.
This is a modern twist that lets you serve lots of seafood in one impressive dish. It’s a little bit of a show-off move, and honestly, why not?
Baked Halibut with Tomatoes & Olives
This Mediterranean-style dish pairs tender halibut with juicy tomatoes and salty olives. The fish turns out firm and flaky every time.
Halibut’s meaty, mild flavor plays nicely with Italian seasonings and Mediterranean ingredients. It’s kind of a blank canvas for big flavors.
Most recipes call for cherry tomatoes, kalamata olives, and lots of fresh herbs. Some cooks toss in capers or garlic for a little extra punch.
- Quick cooking time – Ready in about 20 minutes
- Healthy option – Low in calories, high in protein
- Simple prep – Few ingredients needed
Baked halibut with cherry tomatoes looks bright and festive on the table. Either fresh or frozen halibut works here, don’t stress about perfection.
A drizzle of olive oil, a squeeze of lemon, and a shower of Italian herbs pull it all together. While baking, the tomatoes make a light sauce that’s pretty irresistible.
Serve with crusty bread or toss it with pasta. It’s an easy way to make Christmas Eve feel special.
Fisherman’s Stew
Cioppino is a rustic Italian-American fish stew that brings the taste of the ocean right to your Christmas Eve table. This hearty dish mixes up all sorts of seafood in a tomato and wine broth.
The stew fits perfectly into the Feast of the Seven Fishes tradition. You can go all out with lobster, crab, clams, mussels, halibut, scallops, and shrimp.
- Rich tomato base with white wine
- Multiple seafood varieties in one pot
- Perfect for feeding a crowd
- Traditional Christmas Eve dish
The best part? It’s flexible. Use whatever seafood you find at the market that day, the fresher, the better.
This one-pot meal keeps things simple on a busy holiday. Make the broth ahead, toss in the seafood at the last minute, and serve a festive centerpiece that feels both classic and easygoing.
Conclusion
These eight main fish recipes really capture the spirit of the Feast of the Seven Fishes tradition. Christmas Eve tables everywhere light up with these flavors, honestly.
Each dish has its own way of celebrating this beloved Italian-American custom. Cod, salmon, and sea bass step up as hearty centerpiece options.
Cioppino and seafood pasta bring that cozy, warming vibe that just fits cold December nights. Some recipes keep things simple, while others lean into more elaborate territory.
Families get to pick based on their own kitchen confidence, or maybe just how much time they have. Traditional baccalà ties modern celebrations to those old-school customs.
Pan-seared and baked preparations let you work with whatever kitchen setup you’ve got. These Christmas Eve seafood dishes turn dinner into a real event, honestly.
The variety makes it pretty likely everyone will find something to pile on their plate. Wine pairings add a nice touch to each recipe, and fresh herbs and citrus help brighten up those rich seafood flavors.
If you plan ahead, the evening just feels easier. You can prep a lot of stuff earlier in the day, which is a relief.
The feast celebrates both faith and family traditions. These main dishes anchor a meal that, honestly, might be the thing your family remembers most about the holidays.
